And Why It Fails Without the Right Team
“Leaders eat last.”
“Serve your people, and they will serve your mission.”
“Leadership is not about being in charge; it’s about taking care of those in your charge.”
— Simon Sinek
These powerful quotes have helped push servant leadership into the spotlight over the past decade. And for good reason — the model flips the traditional hierarchy on its head, asking leaders not to command, but to serve.
But here’s the thing nobody talks about enough:
Servant leadership only works if you’ve got self-motivated people on board.
Let’s dig into why.
What Is Servant Leadership, Anyway?
Servant leadership is a model where leaders prioritise the growth, wellbeing, and empowerment of their team members. The idea is that by supporting the people doing the work, the leader ultimately drives better outcomes for the team, the business, and even society.
Popularised by thought leaders like Robert Greenleaf and Simon Sinek, servant leadership is built on trust, empathy, active listening, and a long-term focus on people over profit.
In theory, it’s beautiful. In practice… it depends.
Why It Sometimes Fails
1. Not Everyone Is Self-Motivated
Servant leadership thrives when people take initiative, care deeply about their work, and feel a sense of ownership. But if your team lacks internal drive or discipline, servant leadership can backfire — fast.
Without accountability, a supportive leader becomes an enabler. And the team? Disengaged, underperforming, and directionless.
“You can’t light a fire in someone who doesn’t want to burn.”
2. It Requires High Trust – On Both Sides
Servant leaders give trust before it’s earned. They empower their teams upfront. But if that trust isn’t respected or reciprocated, performance can slide. In low-trust environments, servant leadership can feel like weakness, not strength.
3. Not Every Culture Is Ready for It
In some workplace cultures — especially hierarchical or traditionally structured environments — servant leadership can seem confusing or ineffective. Employees may expect direction, not collaboration. They may mistake empowerment for lack of leadership.
4. Burnout Risk for the Leader
Servant leaders often go above and beyond — carrying emotional weight, supporting struggling staff, and sacrificing their own needs. Without boundaries, this can lead to leader burnout.
When It Works Beautifully
Servant leadership shines in teams where:
-
People are internally driven and aligned with the mission
-
There’s psychological safety and mutual respect
-
Team members value autonomy and personal growth
-
The organisation values long-term development over short-term results
-
Leadership is a two-way street — with feedback flowing both ways
In these conditions, servant leaders inspire loyalty, creativity, and exceptional performance. Teams flourish because they’re trusted, not controlled.
The South African Reality Check
In South Africa, many teams operate in high-stress, high-pressure environments. There’s often a mix of cultural backgrounds, leadership expectations, and historical baggage. Servant leadership can be powerful here — especially when it helps people feel seen and supported — but it must be implemented wisely.
Servant leadership is not soft.
It’s intentional. Strategic. And only effective when your team is ready for it.
So, Should You Be a Servant Leader?
Absolutely — if:
✅ You’ve built a team of motivated, accountable people
✅ You’re willing to set clear expectations alongside empowerment
✅ You lead with empathy and clarity
✅ You’re committed to long-term growth, not just short-term control
If not?
You may need to first focus on team development, trust-building, and hiring the right people — before the servant leadership model can take root.
Final Word
Servant leadership isn’t magic.
It’s a powerful tool — but like any tool, it’s only as good as the people using it.
Lead by serving, yes.
But also lead by knowing your team, your context, and yourself.
